Should she be told the truth?

Should she be told the truth?

My fiancé is in a situation and I myself may not be sure how I feel about this at times…he dated this girl and lived with her for about 4 ½ years, her daughter was 6 months old when they moved in together.  The child’s mother is a narcissist which makes it very hard for my fiancé to talk to her in any way shape, form or fashion.  The child is now almost 6 years old. Real biological dad isn’t in the picture and doesn’t want to be evidently.

I would like opinions on something…

Let’s say you started dating someone that had a baby… I mean young baby that couldn’t even talk or walk, and you dated this person and raised their kid as your own. Through the years, no other discussions came up that would be required to discuss with the baby about the dad situation. Until…you break up, but you still act as a parental figure in their lives without legal ties, the child still does not know.  Do you immediately tell the kid you are not the parent? Do you expect the actual parent to tell them? Or do you just let it go?  How do you think this kid will feel if they find out the truth?

I want honest opinions…  I am well aware you can still be a parental figure in the child’s life without being blood… so I understand that part.  My question is more about the lying / omitting this big truth and them later finding out it was all a lie.
I am concerned for this kid’s emotional health, she’s already is learning her mother’s bad habits and when you throw emotional abuse in there by refraining from telling her the truth about her ‘dads’.

2 thoughts on “Should she be told the truth?”

  1. It is a difficult one, I was in a similar situation. My ex denounced my daughter when we split to everyone but her.
    I found it hard to tell her but tell her I did. A few difficult years ensued as well as an estrangement.
    I became the bad person, she developed a close relationship with her step father, who denounced her.
    Now we have a form of relationship, not a mother daughter one but its something. My answer to this would to tell the child from the moment they become understands and not like me leave it till she was a teenager.

  2. Yes, the child needs to know the truth. Then she can decide if she wants to pursue a relationship with the biological father or if the loving step father is all she needs. Truth is healing.

Comments are closed.

Comments are closed.

Privacy Preference Center

Necessary

Advertising

Analytics

Other